Walking through the doors, the first thing that hits you is that unmistakable aroma – a tantalizing blend of butter, spices, and freshly prepared seafood that makes your stomach immediately file a ...

Tucked away in the charming coastal town of Nokomis, Captain Eddie’s seafood restaurant serves up slices of key lime pie so divine, you might suspect they’ve hired mermaids as pastry chefs.

So to find the best store-bought option, we wrangled a few friends of The Kitchn and spent an afternoon tasting a whopping 12 ...